| Player | Position | School | Year |
| First Team | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Pete Cacciatore | MF | St. Mary's | SR |
| Cameron Carver | D | O'Hara | SR |
| Andrew Clifton | F | O'Hara | SR |
| Ryan Cravens | MF | Fulton | JR |
| Tyler Cuba | F | Cape Notre Dame | JR |
| Zach Hoette | GK | Rosary | JR |
| Kyle Hogge | D | O'Hara | SR |
| Trevor House | D | Whitfield | JR |
| Morgan Humphrey | D | Warrensburg | JR |
| Allen JuJic | MF | Affton | SR |
| Steve LaGrand | D | Duchesne | SR |
| Ryan McInerney | F | O'Hara | SR |
| Jeff Menke | MF | Rosary | SR |
| Anthony Palazollo | MF | Whitfield | SR |
| Steve Penn | MF | St. Charles West | SR |
| Adam Prasanphanich | F | Cape Notre Dame | JR |
| Jonny Streumph | D | Helias | SR |
| Bryan Thomas | F | St. Charles West | SR |
| Jason Vilmer | D | St. Mary's | SR |
| Scott Wittenborn | MF | Cape Notre Dame | SR |
| Jake Wylie | MF | Kearney | SR |
| Second Team | |||
| Mark Blankenship | D | St. Mary's | SR |
| Rob Brown | MF | St. Mary's | SR |
| Jason Burroughs | MF | St. Charles West | SR |
| Damian Cook | D | Sacred Heart | SR |
| Matt Fennessey | GK | Union | SR |
| Adam Garrett | F | Sikeston | SR |
| David Greathouse | GK | Whitfield | SR |
| Ryan Heimberger | MF | Rosary | SR |
| Duane Kahler | GK | O'Hara | SO |
| Jimmy Koch | D | St. Charles West | SO |
| Deek Kruse | F | Westminster | SR |
| Josh Marchbank | D | Kearney | JR |
| Juan Mejia | F | Monett | SR |
| Chris Meyero | GK | Duchesne | JR |
| Steve Monsanto | MF | Ozark | SR |
| Joe Nelson | D | St. Mary's | SR |
| Eddy Parker | F | Lutheran South | SR |
| Matt Pobst | D | Cape Notre Dame | SR |
| Michael Ragsdale | MF | O'Hara | JR |
| Dan Schnurr | MF | Helias | SR |
| Andy Sharp | F | Moberly | SR |
| Travis Siebert | GK | Cape Notre Dame | JR |
| Robert Stillings | MF | Willard | SR |
| Dan Taylor | MF | Whitfield | SR |
| Paul Thompson | MF | Marshall | SR |
| Matt Weant | D | Moberly | SR |
| Honorable Mention | |||
| Alen Basic | F | St. Mary's | JR |
| Matt Brennan | D | Duchesne | JR |
| Michael Brozman | F | Pembroke Hill | SR |
| Marco Cecenas | D | Monett | SR |
| Casey Cochran | GK | Warrensburg | SR |
| Drew Glover | MF | Warrensburg | SR |
| Jason Jacob | MF | O'Hara | FR |
| Nathan LeGrand | D | Cape Notre Dame | SR |
| Ryan Mueller | F | Helias | SR |
| John Ryan | D | St. Mary's | SR |
| Chip Schellhorn | D | Pembroke Hill | SR |
| David Stair | MF | Westminster | JR |
