| Player | School | Position | Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ryan Belcher | Mexico | F | JR |
| Chris Bunch | Cole Camp | D | SR |
| Damian Cook | Sacred Heart | D | JR |
| Ryan Cravens | Fulton | D | SO |
| Jimmy Crutchfield | Moberly | GK | SR |
| Justin Davis | Stover | D | JR |
| Fernando Diez-Pineyro | MMA | F | SR |
| Hugo Farfan | Marshall | F | FR |
| Luke Gieschen | Smithton | D | JR |
| Nils Gola | Marshall | MF | SR |
| Stephen Hoell | Fulton | MF | SR |
| J.D. Knight | Stover | F | SR |
| Lucas McNeal | Northwest | F | SR |
| Dan Miller | Moberly | D | SR |
| Seamus O’Donnell | Fulton | F | SR |
| Jimmy O’Loughlin | Moberly | MF | SR |
| Cole Prenger | Helias | MF | SR |
| Garrett Portra | Fulton | GK | SR |
| Jonny Streumph | Helias | D | JR |
| Paul Thompson | Marshall | D | JR |
| Matt Watkins | Smithton | GK | JR |
